Is Publishing in a High School Journal Worth It?

Uploaded

Short answer. It can be, if your work is finished, you have checked the journal, and you can accept the fee and the wait. It is optional. No admissions page we opened says a publication is expected, so weigh what you learn and can show against the cost, the revision time and the risk of a weak venue.

Key takeaways

  • Publishing is optional, and no school page we opened says applicants are expected to have a publication.
  • Costs are fees plus time. Review length varies by journal and by time of year, so ask the journal.
  • Vet the journal first, because a weak venue adds cost without adding much to show.
  • A class talk, a science fair or a clear write-up can share good work without a journal.

This guide belongs to our walkthrough on how to do research in high school. Publishing is the last and most optional step, so the useful question is whether it fits your project, your budget and your timeline.

Is publishing in a high school journal worth it?

It is worth it when it matches what you want from the project. If you want practice writing a full paper, answering reviewer comments and meeting a submission process, a journal gives you all three. If you mainly want to show colleges that you did research, publishing is only one way to do that, and it is not required.

Two program-run blogs disagree about this, which is itself useful. One says publishing is not essential and that the process matters more than the outward marker.[6] The other says it is one of the most important signals for young researchers, but not the only one.[7] Both are written by organizations that run programs, so treat them as claims, not as findings.

The sensible approach is to decide on your own goals first. Finished work, a venue you have checked and a cost you can accept make publishing reasonable. Unfinished work, a venue that found you by email, or a fee you cannot explain make it a poor bet.

What does it cost in money and time?

Costs come in two forms: fees and waiting. Journals differ widely, so use the journal’s own pages, not a roundup. This table uses one student journal as an example of what to look for.

Question to askExample from one student journal
Is there a submission fee?Yes, $49 at submission, with waivers available on request[3]
Is there a second fee if accepted?It states there is no separate publication fee[3]
Who submits?An adult, because student authors may not submit their own manuscript[3]
How long does review take?It varies by time of year, volume and how complete the revisions are[3]
Can you speed it up?It states it cannot expedite any manuscript, and works in the order received[4]

The point is the questions, not this journal’s answers, which can change. A trustworthy journal explains what its fees are for, when they are charged and whether waivers exist.[1] DOAJ requires its listed journals to state every fee from submission to publication, and to state it when there are none.[2]

What do schools say about publications?

The pages we opened say little. The Common App describes its Activities section as the place to share interests outside the classroom, and treats academic honors as a separate item.[5] It does not tell applicants to list a publication, and it does not say how readers weigh one.

We found no admissions office page that says a publication is expected. That matches how most students apply: many strong applicants have no paper at all. What readers can see is your description of what you did, so accuracy matters more than the venue. Our guide on how to describe research on the Common App covers wording, and the hub does research help college admissions? covers what schools publish about research. Neither source shows that a publication changes a decision.

How do you decide whether to submit?

Work through these checks in order. If you stall on one, that is your answer for now.

  1. Is the work finished? A complete write-up with methods and limits is the minimum for review.
  2. Did you find the journal, or did it find you? Journals you chose are safer than unsolicited invitations.
  3. Does the journal pass vetting? Run the steps in our guide on how to spot a predatory journal, including the Think. Check. Submit. questions on peer review, publisher contact and fees.[1]
  4. Can you accept the fee and the wait? Ask the journal for its current fee, waiver rules and typical review time before you commit.
  5. Is there an adult who can help? Some journals require one to submit on your behalf.[3]
  6. Do you have a plan if it is rejected? Rejection is a normal outcome, and you can revise or choose another venue.

What can you do instead of publishing?

You can share good work without a journal. Present it to a class or club, enter a science fair, post a clear write-up with your data and methods, or ask your mentor for feedback on a draft. Each lets you say honestly what you did and what you found. If you are still building the project, our guides on doing research without a lab and the hub for the whole process show how to get to a finished result first.

What do we not know?

We do not know how any admissions reader weighs a publication, and we found no school page that says. Fees, review times and eligibility rules change, and the example journal above is one of many with different terms, so confirm each journal’s current pages. The two program blogs we read have a stake in what students believe about publishing, so their views are claims and not evidence. Whether a given journal counts as strong depends on your field and your goals, and the checks here cannot judge a specific journal for you.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need to publish to show I did real research?
No. Publishing is one way to share work, not a requirement. You can describe finished work you presented, wrote up or entered in a fair, and say exactly what it was.
Can I submit to a journal by myself as a student?
It depends on the journal. One student journal states that student authors may not submit their own manuscript and that an adult must do it, so read the author rules first.
Is a journal that charges a fee always predatory?
No. Fees alone do not decide it. Check that the journal explains what the fee covers, when it applies and whether waivers exist, and then check peer review and the publisher.

Sources

  1. Think. Check. Submit., checklist for choosing a journal
  2. DOAJ, guide for journals applying for inclusion
  3. Journal of Emerging Investigators, submission FAQ
  4. Journal of Emerging Investigators, review process page
  5. Common App, first-year students
  6. Research program blog, is it worth it for high school students to publish a paper
  7. Education company guide to publishing high school research